The Times calls in Michael Roth, the president of Wesleyan University, to write a bizarre anti-Zionist book review:
Mr. Wolfe surveys important writers in the particularist and universalist traditions. He offers a stinging account of how casual but rancid bigotry has become an acceptable dimension for particularist Jewish writers committed to defending their own. Even with serious scholars like the Harvard professor Ruth R. Wisse and sensitive writers like Cynthia Ozick, Mr. Wolfe shows that empathy and principle evaporate into preening chauvinism and callous disregard for others.
If the Times is going to describe Ruth Wisse and Cynthia Ozick as bigots, fairness would dictate that they at least be given a chance to respond or defend themselves.